Google Ads Agency Red Flags: 9 Signs to Walk Away (and What to Ask Instead)

Most bad Google Ads relationships look fine for the first three months. The reports arrive, the charts go up, and only later does the business owner discover that the account was never theirs, that the cost line included a markup, or that nobody had looked at the search terms since launch.

The good news is that almost every one of those problems is visible before you sign, and several are covered by Google’s own rules for agencies. This guide lists the nine we watch for, what a good answer sounds like, and where Google’s policy backs you up. It sits alongside our Google Ads management playbook, which explains what the work itself should involve.

What Are the Red Flags When Hiring a Google Ads Agency?

1. The account will be created in their name

If the agency builds your campaigns inside an account it owns, your history, your conversion data and your learnings leave with them. Google Ads has five access levels: Email-only, Billing, Read-only, Standard and Admin. Only Admin users can add or remove other users. The account should be in your business’s name, and you should be an Admin. The agency then links its manager account to yours.

2. They will not give you your customer ID

Every Google Ads account has a ten-digit customer ID. Google’s third-party policy requires agencies to provide it when the customer asks, so that Google can investigate and help if something goes wrong. If an agency hesitates over a number Google says is yours, treat that as the answer to question one.

3. You cannot see the fee, or the ad spend includes a markup

Google requires agencies that charge a management fee to tell new customers in writing before their first purchase, and to show the fee on every invoice. When they report Google costs, they must report the exact amount Google charged, without their own fees added. If ad spend is billed through the agency rather than on your own card, ask to see Google’s invoice. If they will not show it, you do not know what you are paying for clicks.

4. The report shows clicks, not leads

Clicks, impressions and clickthrough rate are useful to the person running the account. They are not what you are buying. A monthly report for a local business should lead with calls, form fills and bookings, and the cost of each. If conversion tracking is not set up, the agency cannot report leads, and Google’s automated bidding cannot find them either.

5. You never see the search terms

The search terms report shows the actual searches that triggered your ads. It is where wasted spend shows up first, usually as job seekers, people looking for free help, and searches from areas you do not serve. Ask to see it, and ask when negative keywords were last added. An account that has not had a new negative keyword in a month is not being managed closely.

6. They guarantee results

“Guaranteed first position” or “guaranteed 50 leads a month” should end the conversation. Where an ad appears depends on an auction that recalculates for every search, using your bid, ad and landing page quality, the searcher’s context and what competitors are doing. Google’s third-party policy prohibits false, misleading or unrealistic claims about the results advertisers can expect. A good agency talks about a process and ranges, not promises.

7. A long contract with no way out

Most of what an agency does in Google Ads is visible within a couple of months. A long minimum term with no exit clause protects the agency, not you. Read the cancellation terms and ask what happens to the account and data if you leave. The right answer is that the manager account is unlinked and you keep everything.

Setup fees deserve the same scrutiny. In our check of 13 PPC agencies’ pricing pages, four of the seven that published prices charged a setup fee, and those fees ran from $200 to $750. One listed its fee with a note to call to have it waived. A setup fee far above that range should come with a clear list of what it pays for.

8. A percentage of spend with no cap and a push to spend more

Charging a percentage of ad spend is common and not wrong in itself. Agencies that quote industry ranges put it at 10 to 20% of spend. The issue is incentive: the agency earns more when you spend more, even when the better answer is to target tighter and spend less. In our pricing check, a flat fee and a percentage fee crossed over at about $4,000 a month of spend. If you are on a percentage, ask for a cap, and be wary of a budget increase recommended without lead data behind it.

9. The Google Partner badge is offered as proof of quality

The Google Partner badge means the agency met Google’s thresholds for things like ad spend across its clients, optimization score and team certifications. It shows the agency is active on Google Ads. It does not measure whether your account will produce leads. Treat it as a minimum, then ask the questions in the next section.

What Should You Ask a Google Ads Agency Before Hiring?

These questions take ten minutes on a call. The answers tell you more than a proposal deck.

What Does a Good Google Ads Agency Look Like?

The opposite of each red flag, mostly. A good agency tells you its fee before you ask, insists that the account and billing are yours, sets up call and form tracking before spending a dollar, shows you the search terms report without being asked, and reports in leads and cost per lead. It also tells you when not to spend, for example when your landing page or tracking needs fixing first.

That is the standard we hold ourselves to, and the reason our audit report is yours to keep whether or not you hire us.

Frequently Asked Questions